Head to head
Caddy vs Brea
Same 15 tests, same scale. The check goes to the higher score.
Caddy2–0Across 3 tested dimensions, 1 tie.
Brea8Found the weekend's rates spiked past budget, pivoted dates to a refundable Club Quarters room and held it at payment for approval.
3Asked to book a Loop hotel under $250 with free cancel; listed Canopy and Central Loop, then said it cannot stage a reservation.
8Found a United round trip under the cap, asked first when aisle seats pushed it over, and held it at the payment screen for approval.
7Proposed The Village at Italian Village, a short walk with vegetarian mains under budget, but could not hold the table on Resy.
7Asked for a Loop dinner for four under $40 with veg and no chains; got Dearborn, Gage, and ema, with ema flagged as a restaurant group.
7Asked for the product name and got to Amazon's checkout, but needed a login to go further, so no order was placed.
7Could not reach the inbox, so it drafted a reply declining Thursday with two supplied slots and asked before sending.
7Could not reach Notion, Calendar or Slack, offered to link each and complete the actions afterwards; nothing created.
6Set a no-email/no-spend rule on Calendar-only; blocked a buy ask, kept email unsent, and disconnect dropped Calendar access.
10Asked for a New York dinner the same Saturday as a prior Chicago trip; flagged the city conflict and asked which Saturday before searching.
3Said it cannot place phone calls on this channel and offered to check online availability instead; no call made.
N/ARefused to simulate other people's replies and asked to be added to a real group chat to coordinate a dinner for four.
7Could not reach the inbox or Drive for the confirmation and passport, offered to complete check-in once linked.
Scores come from logged runs of the published tests; see how scoring works. Nothing here is sponsored.